Skip to main content

Town of Brookhaven, Suffolk County

Setauket,
New York.

Setauket and East Setauket are hamlets in the Town of Brookhaven, Suffolk County, set between Stony Brook and Port Jefferson on Long Island's North Shore. Colonial era and nineteenth century homes and farmhouses line the older roads near the village green, and capes, ranches and colonials fill later developments. Team Rivera, Steven and Rose Rivera of Keller Williams Points North, lists and sells homes in Setauket and helps buyers there.

By at Keller Williams Points North. Updated .

What is your Setauket home worth?

An automated estimate first. If you want a closer read, we will prepare a comparative market analysis. No obligation to list.

What is my home worth?
110 Google reviews, 5.0 rating

Where is Setauket and how do you get around?

Landmarks
The village green, Culper Spy Ring history
Rail
Stony Brook and Port Jefferson stations nearby
Water
Setauket Harbor and Conscience Bay
Parks
Frank Melville Memorial Park

What kinds of homes are in Setauket?

Setauket and East Setauket sit between Stony Brook and Port Jefferson in the Town of Brookhaven. The area was settled in the colonial era, and during the Revolutionary War it was home base for the Culper Spy Ring, the network of local residents who passed intelligence to George Washington. That history is still part of the landscape.

The Setauket village green anchors the old center, surrounded by historic buildings. Nearby, Frank Melville Memorial Park wraps around a mill pond with walking paths. To the north, Setauket Harbor and Conscience Bay sit off Port Jefferson Harbor, so boating and water views are part of life along the shore.

The housing stock reflects that long history. Around the green and along the older roads there are colonial era and nineteenth century homes, farmhouses, and restored historic properties. Capes, ranches, split levels, and colonials fill later developments, many on wooded lots, and some newer colonials were built on larger parcels. Waterfront and water view homes line parts of the harbors. Historic homes can come with preservation considerations, and we help sellers present them well and help buyers understand them before making an offer.

North Country Road runs through Setauket and East Setauket, connecting west to Stony Brook and east to Port Jefferson. Nesconset Highway runs to the south. Setauket has no LIRR station of its own, but the Stony Brook and Port Jefferson stations on the Port Jefferson Branch are close. We work Setauket listings and buyer searches from our Saint James office and know the roads and the history that shape value here.

What should sellers in Setauket know?

A colonial era or nineteenth century home near the Setauket village green leads with its history, so we gather the details buyers will ask about, preservation considerations included, and put them up front. A later colonial on a wooded lot, or a home with a view of Setauket Harbor or Conscience Bay, is priced against its own kind of sales.

What should buyers in Setauket know?

Buying in Setauket can mean choosing between a restored historic home on the older roads, a cape or colonial in a later development, or a spot on the water. We help you understand what an older home involves before you make an offer, and since Setauket has no station of its own, we factor in the Stony Brook and Port Jefferson stations if you ride the train.

Questions

Questions about Setauket.

Are Setauket and East Setauket hamlets, and what town are they in?
Yes, Setauket and East Setauket are hamlets in the Town of Brookhaven, Suffolk County, between Stony Brook and Port Jefferson. The Town's Route 25A visioning report lists both as hamlets and runs east to the Poquott Village line, so Poquott is a separate village.
Is there an LIRR station in Setauket?
No, Setauket has no station of its own. Riders use the Stony Brook or Port Jefferson stations on the Port Jefferson Branch, and North Country Road links Setauket west to Stony Brook and east to Port Jefferson. Nesconset Highway runs to the south.
What history and parks are in Setauket?
The Setauket village green anchors the old center, and Frank Melville Memorial Park wraps around a mill pond with walking paths. The Town of Brookhaven notes that General George Washington relied on information from the Culper Spy Ring, which operated out of Setauket during the War for American Independence. Setauket Harbor and Conscience Bay sit to the north, off Port Jefferson Harbor.
How do I check a Setauket home's flood zone?
Look up the address on FEMA's Flood Map Service Center and check the zone on the current map, which matters most for homes along Setauket Harbor and Conscience Bay. If you think the map is wrong for a parcel, FEMA says you can submit data to amend or revise it through the Letter of Map Change process once the community has adopted the maps.
What taxes apply when a Setauket home is sold?
Setauket sales carry two state taxes: the seller pays the base transfer tax, and the buyer pays a mansion tax of 1% once the price reaches $1 million, according to the Department of Taxation and Finance's memo TSB-M-19(1)R and its transfer tax page, both read November 20, 2026. The memo notes that when a buyer fails to pay, the seller is required to, and that the transfer taxes added in 2019 apply only to conveyances within New York City, so they do not reach a home in Setauket or East Setauket. Ask us for a net sheet before you list.

More guides near Setauket.

Every town guide

Sources

  1. Supervisor Romaine and Councilwoman Cartright Announce Completion of Area Visioning Report

    Town of Brookhaven, read

    The report covers Route 25A from the Smithtown / Brookhaven Town line in the west to the Poquott Village line in the east and includes the hamlets of Stony Brook, Setauket and East Setauket, including the Stony Brook University area along Route 25A.

  2. Growth of Brookhaven

    Town of Brookhaven, read

    General George Washington relied on information supplied by the Culper Spy Ring, which operated out of Setauket, during the War for American Independence

  3. Flood Maps

    Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), read

    Any time after your community adopts the maps, you can submit data to amend or revise the flood map through the Letter of Map Change (LOMC) process.

  4. Summary of Amendments to New York’s Real Estate Transfer Taxes

    New York State Department of Taxation and Finance, read

    The base tax is paid by the seller (grantor).

  5. Real estate transfer tax

    New York State Department of Taxation and Finance, read

    An additional tax (mansion tax) of 1% of the sale price applies to residences where consideration is $1 million or more.

  6. Summary of Amendments to New York’s Real Estate Transfer Taxes

    New York State Department of Taxation and Finance, read

    The Tax Law was amended to provide that when the buyer fails to pay the tax, the seller (grantor) is required to pay.

  7. Summary of Amendments to New York’s Real Estate Transfer Taxes

    New York State Department of Taxation and Finance, read

    The recently Enacted Budget (Chapter 59 of 2019) amended the existing mansion tax and added several new real estate transfer taxes that apply only to conveyances within New York City.

Setauket

Talk to us about Setauket.

Selling, buying, or both in Setauket? Call, text, or send the form, and Steven or Rose will get back to you.

Ask Steven and Rose

Tell us a little about your plans. Steven or Rose will get back to you.

Asking a question

Add a note (optional)

Steven or Rose reads every note.

We use your details to reply to your request. See our privacy policy.

110 Google reviews, 5.0 rating

Steven and Rose were super quick to respond to whatever questions I had and helped me along the way with a process I was not that familiar with at all. Can’t thank them enough!

Mike Kryger, Google review

As featured in Business Insider, 2026 Rising Stars of Real Estate

Rose Rivera and Steven Rivera of Team Rivera

Steven or Rose reads every note.