Skip to main content

Town of Islip, Suffolk County

Islip,
New York.

Main Street shops, the Great South Bay across from Fire Island, and the canals at Bayberry Point.

What is your Islip home worth?

An automated estimate first. If you want a closer read, we will prepare a comparative market analysis. No obligation to list.

What is my home worth?
110 Google reviews, 5.0 rating

Where is Islip and how do you get around?

Downtown
Main Street
Rail
Islip station, LIRR Montauk Branch
Water
The Great South Bay, across from Fire Island
Parks
Seatuck National Wildlife Refuge, the town bathing beach

What kinds of homes are in Islip?

Islip is a hamlet in the Town of Islip, on Long Island's South Shore, and it shares its name with the town. It sits on the north side of the Great South Bay, across the water from Fire Island, with Bay Shore next door to the west.

Main Street is the downtown, a shopping district of gift shops, boutiques, restaurants, and pubs that hosts a festival each spring and a holiday house tour. Down by the bay, the hamlet has its own public bathing beach, run by the town, and the Seatuck National Wildlife Refuge sits at its southeastern corner. Boating is a big part of the waterfront, with Fire Island just across the bay.

Islip's housing has deep roots. Queen Anne Revival homes and other older houses line many streets, and some of the old mansions remain beside newer, larger homes. At Bayberry Point, a small cluster of streets separated by canals runs out to the bay, where several Moorish style houses built for the original development still stand, most of them renovated since. Capes, ranches, and colonials fill the side streets. With historic and waterfront homes, we look closely at age, systems, and flood zone questions before we price them.

The Islip station is on the Montauk Branch of the LIRR, and the Fire Island ferries leave from neighboring Bay Shore. By car, Montauk Highway runs through the hamlet as Main Street, Sunrise Highway, Union Boulevard, and the Heckscher State Parkway cross it, and Islip Avenue heads north from Main Street. Team Rivera serves Islip from our Saint James office, and we come across the island for showings, valuations, and listing appointments here and along the South Shore.

What should sellers in Islip know?

In Islip, a Queen Anne Revival home, a canal front house at Bayberry Point, and a ranch on a side street each sell against their own kind of sales, so we price yours against the ones that truly match. With an older or waterfront home we gather the answers on age, systems, and flood zone before buyers ask, and we come across from Saint James for the listing appointment and the showings.

What should buyers in Islip know?

An Islip search can run from older homes near Main Street to canal front houses at Bayberry Point and capes and ranches on the side streets. We help you weigh the walk to Main Street and the station against being on the water, and we meet you there for showings.

Guides for sellers and buyers.

Every town guide

Islip

Talk to us about Islip.

Selling, buying, or both in Islip? Call, text, or send the form, and Steven or Rose will get back to you.

Ask Steven and Rose

Tell us a little about your plans. Steven or Rose will get back to you.

Asking a question

Add a note (optional)

Steven or Rose reads every note.

We use your details to reply to your request. See our privacy policy.

110 Google reviews, 5.0 rating

Steven and Rose were super quick to respond to whatever questions I had and helped me along the way with a process I was not that familiar with at all. Can’t thank them enough!

Mike Kryger, Google review

As featured in Business Insider, 2026 Rising Stars of Real Estate

Rose Rivera and Steven Rivera of Team Rivera

Steven or Rose reads every note.