Skip to main content

Town of Southold, Suffolk County

Mattituck,
New York.

Mattituck is a hamlet in the Town of Southold, Suffolk County, reaching from Long Island Sound to Peconic Bay on Long Island's North Fork. Housing runs from older homes near Love Lane and farmhouses set among farm fields to cottages near the inlet and the bay. Team Rivera, Steven and Rose Rivera of Keller Williams Points North, lists and sells homes in Mattituck and helps buyers there.

By at Keller Williams Points North. Updated .

What is your Mattituck home worth?

An automated estimate first. If you want a closer read, we will prepare a comparative market analysis. No obligation to list.

What is my home worth?
110 Google reviews, 5.0 rating

Where is Mattituck and how do you get around?

Downtown
Love Lane and Main Road
Rail
Mattituck station, LIRR
Water
Mattituck Inlet on the Sound, Peconic Bay to the south
Landscape
Farmland and vineyards

What kinds of homes are in Mattituck?

Mattituck is a hamlet in the Town of Southold, toward the western end of the town on Long Island's North Fork. Main Road runs through it, and just off Main Road, Love Lane is a short street of shops and restaurants near the Mattituck station.

The hamlet reaches from Long Island Sound to Peconic Bay. On the north side, Mattituck Inlet opens from the Sound, with boats docked along it. To the south, the land runs down to the bay. Farmland and vineyards fill much of the ground in between.

Housing in Mattituck covers a lot of ground. Older homes sit near Love Lane and Main Road, farmhouses stand among the fields, and cottages and water view homes are found near the Sound, the inlet, and the bay. Newer builds on former farmland add to the range, and there is a mix of year round homes and seasonal ones. With that much variety, we compare each house with truly similar sales rather than with the hamlet as a whole.

The Mattituck station is on the LIRR line that runs out to Greenport, and Main Road runs west toward Riverhead and the end of the Long Island Expressway. Team Rivera now serves Mattituck from our Saint James office. We come out for showings, valuations, and listing appointments, and a search here can take in the neighboring North Fork hamlets too.

What should sellers in Mattituck know?

A Mattituck price depends on which side of the hamlet the house is on and what kind of house it is. An older home near Love Lane, a farmhouse with fields around it, and a cottage by Mattituck Inlet or the bay each have their own set of matching sales, and we build the number from those. For a house near the water we check the flood map early, so the answer is ready when buyers ask, and the listing leads with what sets the place apart, whether that is the walk to Love Lane or the view. We drive out from Saint James to meet you and to run the showings.

What should buyers in Mattituck know?

In Mattituck the first question is usually the Sound or the bay. The north side has Mattituck Inlet and its docks, the south side has Peconic Bay, and Love Lane and the station sit in between near Main Road, with farmhouses and fields filling the space around them. An older home close to Love Lane gives you a walk to the shops and the train, while a cottage by the inlet or the bay trades that for the water. We tour each kind with you so the tradeoff is clear.

Questions

Questions about Mattituck.

Is Mattituck its own town?
No, Mattituck is a hamlet, not a town of its own: it sits toward the western end of the Town of Southold in Suffolk County. Its center is Love Lane and the stretch of Main Road around it, and Cutchogue is the next hamlet to the east. Because Mattituck is in the Town of Southold, a sale here follows that town's Peconic Bay region tax rules.
Where do you catch the LIRR in Mattituck?
At the Mattituck station, close to Love Lane just off Main Road, which the MTA lists under Greenport Service. From there the line runs east through Southold to Greenport and west toward Riverhead. For times, use the MTA's current timetable, since we never print schedules on these pages.
What is Mattituck Inlet?
Mattituck Inlet is the opening from Long Island Sound on the north side of the hamlet, with boats docked along its banks. The hamlet's southern edge is on Peconic Bay, so Mattituck touches both the Sound and the bay. Farmland and vineyards fill much of the ground between them.
What transfer taxes come with a Mattituck sale?
Two kinds of transfer tax apply when a Mattituck home changes hands: the New York State tax, which falls on the seller, and the Town of Southold's Peconic Bay region taxes, which fall on the buyer under section 1449-dd of the Tax Law and pass to the seller only if the buyer fails to pay or is exempt. The Department of Taxation and Finance's page, read November 20, 2026, computes the state tax at two dollars for each $500 of the price, and the Town of Southold's FAQ, read the same day, describes a 0.5% housing fee paid by the purchaser, on top of the town's Community Preservation Fund tax. At $1 million and up, the same state page, as read that day, adds a mansion tax of 1%, which section 1402-a puts on the buyer. Your attorney confirms each amount before closing.
How do I find out whether a Mattituck property is in a flood zone?
Search its address on FEMA's flood maps, which FEMA says let you see the relationship between a property and the areas with the highest risk of flooding. That matters here because Mattituck has shoreline on the Sound, the inlet and the bay. FEMA also points out that most homeowners insurance does not cover flood damage, so a buyer near the water should price a separate flood policy before making an offer.

Guides for sellers and buyers.

Every town guide

Sources

  1. Mattituck station

    Metropolitan Transportation Authority, read

    Greenport Service

  2. Real estate transfer tax

    New York State Department of Taxation and Finance, read

    However, if the seller doesn't pay the tax, or is exempt from the tax, the buyer must pay the tax.

  3. Real estate transfer tax

    New York State Department of Taxation and Finance, read

    Tax is computed at a rate of two dollars for each $500, or fractional part thereof, of consideration.

  4. Section 1449-DD, Liability for tax (New York Tax Law)

    New York State Senate, read

    If the grantee has failed to pay the tax imposed pursuant to this article or if the grantee is exempt from such tax, the grantor shall have the duty to pay the tax.

  5. FAQ'S (Community Housing Fund)

    Town of Southold, read

    The primary source of funding are revenues derived from a 0.5% real estate transfer fee paid by the purchaser

  6. Real estate transfer tax

    New York State Department of Taxation and Finance, read

    An additional tax (mansion tax) of 1% of the sale price applies to residences where consideration is $1 million or more.

  7. Section 1402-A, Additional tax (New York Tax Law)

    New York State Senate, read

    the additional tax imposed by this section shall be paid by the grantee.

  8. Flood Maps

    Federal Emergency Management Agency, read

    Using a flood map, you can see the relationship between your property and the areas with the highest risk of flooding.

  9. Flood Insurance

    Federal Emergency Management Agency, read

    Most homeowners insurance does not cover flood damage.

Mattituck

Talk to us about Mattituck.

Selling, buying, or both in Mattituck? Call, text, or send the form, and Steven or Rose will get back to you.

Ask Steven and Rose

Tell us a little about your plans. Steven or Rose will get back to you.

Asking a question

Add a note (optional)

Steven or Rose reads every note.

We use your details to reply to your request. See our privacy policy.

110 Google reviews, 5.0 rating

Steven and Rose were super quick to respond to whatever questions I had and helped me along the way with a process I was not that familiar with at all. Can’t thank them enough!

Mike Kryger, Google review

As featured in Business Insider, 2026 Rising Stars of Real Estate

Rose Rivera and Steven Rivera of Team Rivera

Steven or Rose reads every note.