Town of Islip, Suffolk County
Bay Shore,
New York.
Main Street, the Bay Shore Marina, and the Fire Island ferries at the foot of Maple Avenue.
What is your Bay Shore home worth?
An automated estimate first. If you want a closer read, we will prepare a comparative market analysis. No obligation to list.
What is my home worth?Where is Bay Shore and how do you get around?
- Downtown
- Main Street
- Rail
- Bay Shore station, LIRR Montauk Branch
- Water
- Great South Bay, Bay Shore Marina, Fire Island ferries
- Parks
- Benjamin Beach
What kinds of homes are in Bay Shore?
Bay Shore is a hamlet in the Town of Islip, on Long Island's South Shore along the Great South Bay. The Southern State Parkway marks its northern edge, and the village of Brightwaters sits just west of it, between Bay Shore and West Bay Shore.
Main Street is the downtown, a long stretch of restaurants, boutiques, shops, and offices, brought back with new sidewalks, streetlights, landscaping, and restored parks. Toward the water, the Bay Shore Marina sits on the Great South Bay with Benjamin Beach right beside it. At the southern end of Maple Avenue, ferries leave for Fire Island communities including Ocean Beach, Saltaire, and Kismet.
Bay Shore's housing reflects how it grew. Older homes stand on the streets near Main Street and the bay, and neighborhoods of postwar homes were built on former farms and woodlands. Townhouses and condominiums have gone up on the grounds of old estates, and newer condominiums stand next to the train station. That range means two homes a short walk apart can price very differently, so we compare each house with its own kind.
The Bay Shore station is on the Montauk Branch of the LIRR and is a popular stop for Fire Island, with the ferry terminals just south of it. Montauk Highway runs through town as Main Street, Union Boulevard and Sunrise Highway cross it further north, and the Southern State Parkway runs along its northern edge. Team Rivera serves Bay Shore from our Saint James office, and we come across the island for showings, valuations, and listing appointments here and along the South Shore.
What should sellers in Bay Shore know?
In Bay Shore, an older home near Main Street, a postwar house, and a condominium by the station each sell against their own kind of sales, so we price yours against the ones that truly match. The listing makes the most of the downtown, the marina, and the ferries, and we come across from Saint James for the listing appointment and the showings.
What should buyers in Bay Shore know?
Bay Shore runs from older homes near Main Street and the bay to postwar neighborhoods, townhouses on former estate grounds, and condominiums next to the station. We help you weigh being close to the train, the ferries, and Main Street against more space, and we meet you there for showings.
Guides for sellers and buyers.
From the blog
How Is a List Price Set for a House on Long Island?A list price starts with a walk-through, then a comparison to recent sales, active listings, and unsold homes, and ends with a pricing meeting.
From the blog
Steps to Buying Your First Home on Long IslandThe steps to buying a first home on Long Island, in order: consultation, pre-approval, search, offer, attorney review, inspection, appraisal, closing.
From the blog
What Permits and Certificates Do You Need to Sell on LI?Before you list a Long Island home, gather the certificate of occupancy, permits for additions, decks, pools and docks, and the survey. Here is how.
More South Shore communities
- North Shore
- Saint James, Smithtown, Huntington, Commack, Northport, Stony Brook, Setauket, Port Jefferson
- Nassau County
- Woodbury, Syosset, Jericho, Plainview, Garden City, Manhasset, Massapequa
- Queens
- Bayside, Whitestone, Douglaston, Fresh Meadows
Bay Shore
Talk to us about Bay Shore.
Ask Steven and Rose
Tell us a little about your plans. Steven or Rose will get back to you.
Steven and Rose were super quick to respond to whatever questions I had and helped me along the way with a process I was not that familiar with at all. Can’t thank them enough!
As featured in Business Insider, 2026 Rising Stars of Real Estate

Steven or Rose reads every note.

