Town of Southold, Suffolk County
Cutchogue,
New York.
Cutchogue is a hamlet in the Town of Southold, Suffolk County, in the middle of Long Island's North Fork between Mattituck and Peconic. Its homes include historic and older houses near the green, farmhouses among the vineyards, and cottages near Peconic Bay and its creeks. Team Rivera, Steven and Rose Rivera of Keller Williams Points North, lists and sells homes in Cutchogue and helps buyers there.
By Team Rivera at Keller Williams Points North. Updated .
What is your Cutchogue home worth?
An automated estimate first. If you want a closer read, we will prepare a comparative market analysis. No obligation to list.
What is my home worth?Where is Cutchogue and how do you get around?
- Downtown
- Main Road and the village green
- Rail
- Mattituck and Southold stations nearby
- Water
- Peconic Bay, Cutchogue Harbor, and New Suffolk
- Landmarks
- The village green and the Old House
What kinds of homes are in Cutchogue?
Cutchogue is a hamlet in the Town of Southold, in the middle of Long Island's North Fork between Mattituck and Peconic. Its center is on Main Road, where the village green holds a group of historic buildings, among them the Old House, which dates to the seventeenth century.
Vineyards and farm stands line Main Road and the roads around the hamlet, and much of the land between them is still farmed. To the south, the small waterfront hamlet of New Suffolk sits on Peconic Bay, and Cutchogue Harbor and the creeks off the bay shape the shoreline on that side.
The housing stock mixes old and new. Historic homes and older houses sit near the village green and Main Road, farmhouses stand among the vineyards and fields, and cottages and water view homes are found near the bay and its creeks. Newer builds on former farmland round it out, in a mix of year round homes and seasonal ones. Older and historic homes can come with their own questions about age, systems, and maintenance, and we help buyers and sellers plan for them early.
Cutchogue has no LIRR station of its own. The Mattituck and Southold stations are the nearest, and Main Road connects the hamlet to both. Team Rivera now serves Cutchogue from our Saint James office, and we come out for showings, valuations, and listing appointments here and across the North Fork.
What should sellers in Cutchogue know?
Cutchogue homes sort into a few clear kinds, and each is priced from its own sales: the historic and older houses near the village green, the farmhouses set among vineyards and fields, and the cottages and water view homes by Cutchogue Harbor and the creeks off the bay. With an old house, buyers will want to know about the roof, the heating, the wiring and what has been updated, so we help you put those answers together before the listing goes live. Our team comes out from Saint James for the appointment, the photos and the showings.
What should buyers in Cutchogue know?
A Cutchogue search usually comes down to three settings. Near the village green and Main Road are the historic and older houses, where an inspection should look hard at age and systems; among the vineyards are farmhouses with land around them; and down by Cutchogue Harbor, the creeks and New Suffolk are the cottages and water view homes. There is no station in the hamlet, so if you ride the train we treat the trip to Mattituck or Southold as part of the search.
Questions
Questions about Cutchogue.
- Is New Suffolk part of Cutchogue?
- No, New Suffolk is its own small waterfront hamlet on Peconic Bay, just south of Cutchogue, and the Town of Southold lists the two as separate hamlets. A search here often takes in both, since Cutchogue Harbor and the creeks off the bay shape the shoreline between them.
- What is the village green in Cutchogue?
- The village green is the historic center of Cutchogue, on Main Road, where a group of old buildings stands together, among them the Old House, which dates to the seventeenth century. Around it, the older and historic homes of the hamlet give way to vineyards and farm stands. If you are looking at a house near the green, ask early about its age, its systems and any past restoration work.
- How do you get to the LIRR from Cutchogue?
- Cutchogue has no station of its own, so riders use the Mattituck station to the west or the Southold station to the east, both reached along Main Road. Which one is closer depends on where in the hamlet the house sits, and we factor the trip to either station into a search if you plan to take the train.
- Which taxes are due when you sell or buy in Cutchogue?
- Cutchogue follows the Town of Southold's rules, so a sale owes the seller's New York State transfer tax and the buyer's Peconic Bay region taxes. The Department of Taxation and Finance's page, checked November 20, 2026, says the state tax is not to be paid by the buyer except as a contract between seller and buyer provides, and section 1449-dd of the Tax Law, read that day, makes the grantee, the buyer, pay the Peconic Bay region taxes. Section 1449-bb, read the same day, adds a tax of one half of one percent for a town housing fund on top of the preservation fund tax, and the Town of Southold's FAQ says its housing fund followed a November 8, 2022 referendum. The state's mansion tax applies once the price reaches $1 million, the threshold in section 1402-a as read the same day, and the Department of Taxation and Finance says the buyer pays it.
- Who sells homes in Cutchogue?
- Team Rivera of Keller Williams Points North lists and sells Cutchogue homes and works with buyers here, from our office at 523 Lake Avenue in Saint James. Call or text Steven or Rose at (631) 213-2005 to set up a visit.
Guides for sellers and buyers.
From the blog
How Is a List Price Set for a House on Long Island?A list price starts with a walk-through, then a comparison to recent sales, active listings, and unsold homes, and ends with a pricing meeting.
From the blog
Steps to Buying Your First Home on Long IslandThe steps to buying a first home on Long Island, in order: consultation, pre-approval, search, offer, attorney review, inspection, appraisal, closing.
From the blog
What Permits and Certificates Do You Need to Sell on LI?Before you list a Long Island home, gather the certificate of occupancy, permits for additions, decks, pools and docks, and the survey. Here is how.
- Cutchogue home value, a first estimate
- The seller's side of New York closing costs
- Mattituck and Love Lane
- Peconic, between Cutchogue and Southold
Sources
New York State Department of Taxation and Finance, read
such tax shall not be paid directly or indirectly by the grantee (buyer) except as provided in a contract between seller and buyer.
Section 1449-DD, Liability for tax (New York Tax Law)
New York State Senate, read
The real estate transfer tax shall be paid by the grantee.
Section 1449-BB, Imposition of tax (New York Tax Law)
New York State Senate, read
at the rate of one half of one percent of the consideration for such conveyance.
FAQ'S (Community Housing Fund)
Town of Southold, read
The creation of this Fund was enacted by a local law following the voters’ approval in a Town -wide mandatory referendum on the November 8th 2022 ballot.
Section 1402-A, Additional tax (New York Tax Law)
New York State Senate, read
when the consideration for the entire conveyance is one million dollars or more
New York State Department of Taxation and Finance, read
The additional tax (mansion tax) and supplemental tax are paid by the buyer.
More North Fork communities
- North Shore
- Saint James, Smithtown, Huntington, Commack, Northport, Stony Brook, Setauket, Port Jefferson
- Nassau County
- Woodbury, Syosset, Jericho, Plainview, Garden City, Manhasset, Massapequa
- Queens
- Bayside, Whitestone, Douglaston, Fresh Meadows
Cutchogue
Talk to us about Cutchogue.
Ask Steven and Rose
Tell us a little about your plans. Steven or Rose will get back to you.
Steven and Rose were super quick to respond to whatever questions I had and helped me along the way with a process I was not that familiar with at all. Can’t thank them enough!
As featured in Business Insider, 2026 Rising Stars of Real Estate

Steven or Rose reads every note.

