Towns of Huntington and Smithtown, Suffolk County
Commack,
New York.
Commack is an inland North Shore hamlet in Suffolk County, split between the Town of Huntington to the west and the Town of Smithtown to the east. Most homes date from the postwar building decades: high ranches, split levels, colonials, capes and ranches, many since expanded or rebuilt. Team Rivera, Steven and Rose Rivera of Keller Williams Points North, lists and sells homes in Commack and helps buyers there.
By Team Rivera at Keller Williams Points North. Updated .
What is your Commack home worth?
An automated estimate first. If you want a closer read, we will prepare a comparative market analysis. No obligation to list.
What is my home worth?Where is Commack and how do you get around?
- Roads
- Long Island Expressway, Northern State and Sunken Meadow Parkways
- Rail
- Nearby stations on the Port Jefferson and Ronkonkoma Branches
- Parks
- Hoyt Farm Park Preserve
- Township
- Split between Huntington and Smithtown
What kinds of homes are in Commack?
Commack is an inland hamlet that straddles two townships: the western part is in the Town of Huntington and the eastern part is in the Town of Smithtown. It sits just south of Kings Park and East Northport and a short drive from our Saint James office.
Most of the housing went up during the postwar building decades, and the streets show it: high ranches, split levels, colonials, capes, and ranches on regular suburban lots. Over time many have been expanded, renovated, or rebuilt, so the same original model can look very different from house to house. Condition and updates drive a lot of the pricing here, which is why we look closely at interior photos of every comparable sale.
Commack is known for its road access. Jericho Turnpike runs east and west through the hamlet, Veterans Memorial Highway begins here and heads east, and Commack Road runs north and south. The Long Island Expressway, the Northern State Parkway, and the Sunken Meadow Parkway all have exits in or right around Commack, which puts much of Long Island within reach by car. There is no LIRR station in Commack itself, so rail commuters drive to a nearby station on the Port Jefferson Branch or the Ronkonkoma Branch.
Shopping lines Jericho Turnpike and Veterans Memorial Highway. For green space, Hoyt Farm Park Preserve is a nature preserve with trails and a nature center, and the Sunken Meadow Parkway leads north to the beaches on the Sound. Because Commack crosses a township line, taxes, services, and paperwork can differ from one side to the other, and we walk buyers and sellers through what applies to their address.
What should sellers in Commack know?
Many Commack houses started from similar plans, so your price depends on what sets yours apart: the renovation, the expansion, the layout, and the lot. We study the interior photos of every comparable sale, and we walk you through what applies on your side of the township line.
What should buyers in Commack know?
Buying in Commack is mostly about condition and layout, since the high ranches, split levels, and colonials here often began as similar models. We point out what has been updated and what has not, and if you commute by train we factor in the drive to a station on the Port Jefferson or Ronkonkoma Branch.
Questions
Questions about Commack.
- Is Commack in the Town of Huntington or the Town of Smithtown?
- Both. Commack is a hamlet whose western part is in the Town of Huntington and whose eastern part is in the Town of Smithtown, and the Suffolk County Clerk marks it with an asterisk, the sign for an area that lies in multiple townships. Which side a house is on shapes its town taxes, services and paperwork, so we check every Commack address before pricing it.
- Does Commack have an LIRR station?
- No, there is no Long Island Rail Road station in Commack itself. Rail commuters drive to a nearby station on the Port Jefferson Branch or the Ronkonkoma Branch. For drivers, the Long Island Expressway, the Northern State Parkway and the Sunken Meadow Parkway all have exits in or right around Commack, and Veterans Memorial Highway begins here.
- Is there a nature preserve in Commack?
- Yes: Hoyt Farm Nature Preserve in Commack has trails and a nature center. The Town of Smithtown runs it and says Hoyt Farm is only open to Smithtown residents all year round. North of the hamlet, the Sunken Meadow Parkway leads to the beaches on Long Island Sound.
- What taxes apply when a Commack home is sold?
- Whichever town a Commack house is in, its seller owes the state real estate transfer tax and its buyer owes the mansion tax, according to the transfer tax page of the Department of Taxation and Finance, read November 20, 2026, which adds that the seller's tax may not be passed to the buyer except by contract. The mansion tax starts at $1 million, and the department's Form TP-584 instructions, read November 20, 2026, say the consideration for the entire conveyance is what counts toward that test. Property taxes are a separate matter and can differ from one side of the line to the other.
- Who sells homes in Commack?
- Team Rivera handles Commack sales and searches on both the Huntington and Smithtown sides, from our office at 523 Lake Avenue in Saint James. Call or text (631) 213-2005 to start.
More guides near Commack.
From the blog
How Do You Sell a House in Saint James, NY?The steps of selling a house in Saint James, NY, from the walk-through and price to closing, and how location and updates shape the listing.
From the blog
What to Know Before Buying a Home in Saint James, NYHousing from the old center to the wooded lots near the harbor villages, Lake Avenue, the LIRR station, and how a New York purchase works.
- Selling a home in Commack
- Ask for a Commack home value
- The Huntington town guide
- The Smithtown town guide
Sources
Town of Smithtown, read
Hoyt Farm is only open to Smithtown residents ALL year round.
New York State Department of Taxation and Finance, read
such tax shall not be paid directly or indirectly by the grantee (buyer) except as provided in a contract between seller and buyer.
New York State Department of Taxation and Finance, read
The additional tax (mansion tax) and supplemental tax are paid by the buyer.
New York State Department of Taxation and Finance, read
In determining whether the consideration for the conveyance is $1 million or more, the consideration for the entire conveyance must be taken into account.
More North Shore communities
- Nassau County
- Woodbury, Syosset, Jericho, Plainview, Garden City, Manhasset, Massapequa
- Queens
- Bayside, Whitestone, Douglaston, Fresh Meadows
Commack
Talk to us about Commack.
Ask Steven and Rose
Tell us a little about your plans. Steven or Rose will get back to you.
Steven and Rose were super quick to respond to whatever questions I had and helped me along the way with a process I was not that familiar with at all. Can’t thank them enough!
As featured in Business Insider, 2026 Rising Stars of Real Estate

Steven or Rose reads every note.

